Leadership effectiveness has never been more important, more difficult to achieve or more challenging to sustain.
As organisations grow, People Leaders face increasing pressure to boost employee engagement, drive performance, support team wellbeing and deliver commercial results. Yet many leaders are expected to deliver these outcomes without a clear understanding of how their teams are actually experiencing work.
Recent benchmark data from the Best Companies b-Heard survey underscores this growing deficit:
- Leadership is falling behind: It ranks as the third lowest-scoring factor across all Best Companies 8-Factors, ties for the third-greatest decline year-over-year, and 56% of organisations saw their Leadership score drop over the past 12 months (with an average decline of 4.15%).
- Erosion of trust: Out of 10 available Leadership statements, 9 experienced a decline over the past year.
- Disconnect at the top: The lowest-scoring statements highlight a deep perception gap: "My organisation puts profits ahead of its people" scored just 61.21 (and suffered the single biggest Leadership statement drop of 2.46%), while "Senior managers of this organisation do a lot of telling but not much listening" scored barely higher at 61.36.
The reality is that leadership becomes harder as responsibility grows. Managing a small team is one thing. Leading through layers of management, overseeing multiple departments or being accountable for hundreds of employees requires a different approach altogether.
Understanding how to improve leadership effectiveness starts with identifying what great leadership looks like, how to measure leaders’ current performance and how to develop People Leadership capabilities consistently across an organisation.
Why People Leadership Effectiveness Matters
Effective People Leadership has a direct impact on organisational success.
Capable People Leaders engage their direct reports, ensuring that they are motivated and aligned with company goals. Team communication and collaboration improves, and organisations are better positioned to attract, develop and retain talent.
Conversely, ineffective People Leadership can contribute to:
- Lower employee engagement
- A lack of clarity
- Reduced productivity
- Increased employee turnover
- Poor communication
- Lower trust in leadership
- Weaker organisational performance
For organisations looking to improve employee engagement, leadership effectiveness should be a priority.
How Do You Measure Leadership Effectiveness?
Understanding the importance of People Leadership capability is only the first step. The real value comes from using employee feedback to identify current performance and support meaningful leadership development.
Employees experience leadership every day. They understand whether leaders communicate clearly, foster strong teams and support development. This makes employee feedback one of the most valuable sources of insight available to organisations.
Traditional measures such as engagement scores, retention rates and business performance provide useful information, but they only tell part of the story. They measure outcomes. They don't necessarily measure the leadership behaviours that create those outcomes.
To improve leadership effectiveness, organisations need to understand how effectively their People Leaders demonstrate the behaviours that have the greatest impact on employee experience, engagement and performance.
The Three Leadership Behaviours That Matter Most
At Best Companies, the People Leader Index focuses on three critical People Leadership capabilities that underpin effective leadership and high-performing organisations. These leadership behaviours centre on a People Leader's ability to drive success through creating Clarity, building cohesive a Team and acting as a Coach to their direct reports.
1. Creating Clarity
Employees perform at their best when they understand what is expected of them.
Leaders who create clarity help employees understand:
- What success looks like
- Organisational priorities
- Company goals
- Team objectives
- Individual expectations
- How employee roles are impact company goals
Creating Organisational Clarity becomes even more important during periods of growth, change or uncertainty. When leaders communicate clearly and consistently, employees are better equipped to make decisions, prioritise their work and contribute meaningfully to organisational success.
While a lack of clarity can result in a loss of focus and engagement, it is just as likely to create a situation where teams are still working hard, however, their efforts are not helping the organisation to achieve its goals.
2. Building High-Performing Teams
One of the key aspects of People Leadership capability is creating environments where teams can succeed together. People Leaders who build high-performing teams focus on creating:
- Psychological safety
- Trust
- Collabration
- Accountability
- Inclusion
- Engagement
- Performance
They create cultures where employees feel connected to each other, safe to provide ideas and opinions without ridicule, and motivated to contribute towards shared goals.
Strong teams don't emerge by accident. They are built through consistent leadership behaviours that encourage ownership, communication and collective success. For organisations looking at how to improve team engagement, this capability is particularly important.
3. Coaching Their People
One of the strongest indicators of leadership effectiveness is a manager's ability to develop others. Effective People Leaders don't simply manage tasks and deliver results, they help employees grow.
Coaching involves:
- Providing meaningful feedback
- Supporting career growth
- Developing capability
- Building confidence
- Encouraging continuous improvement
Employees who feel supported in their development are more likely to remain engaged, perform at a higher level and see a future within the organisation.
Strong coaching also helps organisations build leadership pipelines and develop future leaders from within.
.jpeg)
The Challenge of Leadership at Scale
Many leadership development programmes focus on individual skills, such as communication, strategic decision-making or performance management.
While valuable, these capabilities fail to address one of the biggest challenges facing growing organisations: leadership at scale.
As organisations grow, people leaders naturally lose direct visibility of the employee experience. It becomes increasingly difficult to understand:
- What employees need from their leaders
- Whether communication is landing effectively
- How engaged teams are
- Where support is needed most
- Which leadership behaviours are driving success
Without meaningful insight, leaders often fall into the trap of making decision based on assumptions rather than evidence.
This makes it harder to identify development opportunities and build leadership capability across an organisation.
The Future of Effective Leadership
The expectations placed on People Leaders continue to evolve.
Today's leaders are expected to support wellbeing, improve employee engagement, drive performance and develop future talent, often across increasingly large and complex teams. Achieving this requires more than intuition; it requires insight.
Organisations that understand how leadership is experienced by employees are better positioned to build stronger leaders, create better workplace cultures and drive long-term success.
Ultimately, the answer to how to improve leadership effectiveness is simple: measure the leadership behaviours that matter, develop them consistently and use employee insight to guide continuous improvement.

.jpeg)
